Salvage prostate cancer treatment

A variety of scenarios and options exist 

Salvage therapy may be offered if the PSA, biopsies and imaging suggest recurrence. 

1

What is it?

Salvage treatment means treatment given when prostate cancer returns or persists after an earlier treatment. 

This can happen after surgery, radiotherapy, focal therapy or other prostate cancer treatments.

Salvage treatment is not one single option. It depends on where the cancer appears to be, what treatment has already been given, the PSA pattern, imaging, biopsy results, symptoms, general health and patient priorities.

The first job is to work out whether the recurrence is:

Local, in the prostate or prostate bed
Regional, in pelvic lymph nodes
Distant, in bones or other organs
Biochemical only, meaning PSA has risen but scans do not yet show a clear site

2

Who is it for?

Who is it for?

Salvage treatment may be considered when there is evidence that prostate cancer has persisted or returned.

This may include:

A PSA that does not fall properly after surgery
A PSA that rises after surgery
A PSA rise after radiotherapy
A recurrence after focal therapy
Cancer seen in pelvic lymph nodes
Cancer seen in the prostate bed
Cancer seen in the prostate after radiotherapy
Cancer seen on MRI or PSMA PET
Symptoms from local recurrence

Not every PSA rise needs immediate treatment. The PSA level, PSA doubling time, original pathology, imaging and patient health all matter.

 

3

Benefits

The aim of salvage treatment is to control cancer that has returned or persisted.

In selected patients, salvage treatment may still be given with curative intent, especially if the recurrence appears local or limited.

Possible benefits include:

Treating cancer in the prostate bed after surgery
Treating cancer left in the prostate after radiotherapy or focal therapy
Treating selected pelvic lymph node recurrence
Delaying or avoiding long-term systemic treatment
Improving local control
Reducing the risk of further progression

The key is careful selection. Salvage treatment can be useful, but it is often more complex than first-line treatment.

4

Risks

Salvage treatment is usually more complicated than treatment given first time around.

Previous surgery, radiotherapy or focal therapy can change tissue planes, blood supply, healing and anatomy.

Possible risks depend on the treatment used, but may include:

Urinary leakage
Erectile dysfunction
Bowel symptoms
Rectal injury
Bleeding
Infection
Scarring
Urethral stricture
Bladder neck narrowing
Urinary retention
Worsening urinary symptoms
Need for further treatment
Side effects from hormone therapy

The risks should be discussed carefully before treatment.

5

Before treatment

Before salvage treatment, the important question is:

Where is the cancer?

Assessment may include:

PSA and PSA trend
PSA doubling time
Review of original pathology
Review of surgical margin status
Review of lymph node findings
MRI
PSMA PET scan
Biopsy in selected cases
Urinary function assessment
Sexual function assessment
Bowel history
Multidisciplinary team discussion

NICE advises that biochemical relapse alone does not always mean treatment must change immediately, and PSA doubling time should be considered when relapse occurs. NICE also recommends radiotherapy to the prostate bed for biochemical relapse after radical prostatectomy when there are no known metastases. (NICE)

6

During treatment

Salvage treatment depends on the previous treatment and where the recurrence appears to be.

Salvage radiotherapy after surgery

Salvage radiotherapy is one of the commonest salvage treatments after radical prostatectomy.

After surgery, the prostate has been removed. If the PSA becomes detectable or rises later, this may suggest cancer cells remain in the prostate bed, lymph nodes or elsewhere.

If there are no known distant metastases, radiotherapy may be offered to the prostate bed, sometimes with treatment to pelvic lymph nodes depending on risk and imaging.

Hormone therapy may also be added in selected cases.

Prostate Cancer UK explains that radiotherapy may be given to the prostate bed after prostate removal if there is concern cancer may return or was not completely removed, and that timing may depend partly on urinary recovery. (Prostate Cancer UK)

Salvage surgery after surgery

Surgery after surgery is less common, but it can be considered in selected cases.

This usually does not mean removing the prostate again, because the prostate has already been removed. It may mean surgery to remove suspicious or proven recurrent lymph nodes in the pelvis.

This is sometimes called salvage lymph node dissection.

It is not suitable for every patient. It depends on where the disease is seen, how many nodes are involved, PSA behaviour, previous treatment, surgical risk and whether other treatments such as radiotherapy or systemic therapy are more appropriate.

The aim may be to reduce visible disease, delay further treatment or help with local control, but the evidence and benefit vary between patients.

Surgery after radiotherapy

Surgery after radiotherapy is called salvage prostatectomy.

This means removing the prostate after previous radiotherapy when cancer appears to have returned within the prostate.

This is a difficult operation. Radiotherapy can cause scarring, altered tissue planes, reduced healing capacity and tissue fragility. This can increase the risk of urinary leakage, rectal injury, strictures, erectile dysfunction and other complications.

Surgery after radiotherapy may be considered only in carefully selected men, usually after imaging and biopsy confirmation of local recurrence.

It should be performed only in specialist hands and after detailed counselling.

Salvage treatment after focal therapy

If cancer persists or returns after focal therapy, options may include:

Repeat focal therapy
Radical prostatectomy
Radiotherapy
Hormone therapy
Active monitoring in selected cases

Recurrence after focal therapy may be:

In-field, meaning recurrence in the treated area
Out-of-field, meaning cancer elsewhere in the prostate

This matters because focal therapy treats a target, not necessarily the whole prostate.

MRI, PSA and repeat biopsy are usually important before deciding on further treatment.

Proton beam therapy

Proton beam therapy is a type of radiotherapy that uses protons rather than standard X-rays.

It may reduce radiation dose to some surrounding tissues in certain cancers and anatomical situations. However, for prostate cancer, its routine role is more limited and should be discussed with a clinical oncologist.

NHS England’s policy has stated that proton beam therapy for prostate cancer is not supported except within trials or registration studies because more evidence is needed. (NHS England)

That does not mean proton therapy is never discussed, but patients should understand whether it is being offered as standard care, trial treatment, private treatment or within a registry.

Focal salvage therapy

Focal therapy can sometimes be considered as salvage treatment, especially after radiotherapy if recurrence appears localised within the prostate.

Options may include HIFU, cryotherapy, irreversible electroporation or other focal approaches.

This requires careful imaging and usually biopsy confirmation. The key issue is whether the recurrence is genuinely localised and treatable.

Focal salvage treatment may reduce some side effects compared with whole-gland salvage treatment, but it also carries risks of persistent disease, recurrence and need for further treatment.

 

7

After treatment

Follow-up depends on which salvage treatment has been used.

It may include:

PSA monitoring
MRI
PSMA PET in selected cases
Biopsy in selected cases
Urinary function review
Bowel function review
Erectile function support
Oncology follow-up
Urology follow-up

The PSA pattern after salvage treatment is important. The expected PSA behaviour differs depending on whether the prostate has been removed, remains in place, or whether treatment was focal.

8

Has it worked?

This depends on the treatment.

After salvage radiotherapy following surgery, PSA should fall or stabilise.

After salvage prostatectomy, PSA should usually fall to a very low or undetectable level.

After focal salvage treatment, PSA may fall but does not usually become undetectable because prostate tissue remains.

Success is judged by:

PSA response
PSA doubling time
Imaging findings
Biopsy findings where needed
Symptoms
Need for further treatment

Cancer Research UK explains that after radical treatment, follow-up usually includes PSA blood tests, and rising PSA may suggest prostate cancer cells remain or have returned. (Cancer Research UK)

9

Questions to ask

Where does the cancer appear to be?
Is this a local, regional or distant recurrence?
Is my PSA rise enough to treat now?
What is my PSA doubling time?
Do I need PSMA PET or MRI?
Do I need a biopsy before salvage treatment?
Is salvage radiotherapy appropriate after surgery?
Do I need hormone therapy with salvage radiotherapy?
Is pelvic lymph node treatment needed?
Is salvage lymph node surgery an option?
Is surgery possible after radiotherapy?
What are the risks of salvage prostatectomy?
Could focal salvage treatment be suitable?
Is proton beam therapy relevant in my case?
What happens if salvage treatment does not work?
Would a second opinion help?

11

Need further help?

Private consultations with Mr Anthony Bates are available through Prostatology for raised PSA, MRI review, biopsy results, treatment planning and second opinions.

Book through Prostatology: 
https://www.prostatology.co.uk/consultations

©Copyright. All rights reserved.

Information icon

We need your consent to load the translations

We use a third-party service to translate the website content that may collect data about your activity. Please review the details in the privacy policy and accept the service to view the translations.